Showing posts with label Canton Comprehensive Plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canton Comprehensive Plan. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

PART 2: THE COST OF INEFFECTIVE "CANTON" LEADERSHIP OVER DECADES? $460,000 MM OR NEARLY 1/2 BILLION!

UPDATE:  3:20 PM  - VIDEOS ADDED  


LAST NIGHT
CANTON CITY COUNCIL
ADOPTED
A $350,000 
TAXPAYER PAID FOR
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN

BUT IS


VIDEOS

Canton City Council
Passes
Comprehensive Plan
Including Remarks 
by
Chris Smith (Ward 4)
Kevin Fisher (Ward 5)
Edmond Mack (Ward 8)
President Allen Schulman 

========================

Mayor Thomas M. Bernabei
Hiring of Planner
&
Implementation of Plan

On March 1st, the SCPR published Part 1 in this series (LINK).


The theme of the March 1st blog was that Canton finds itself in a 460MM hole in having an up-to-date city in terms of its infrastructure and there are names to be named going back decades in the context of Canton legislative (city council) and executive (the mayor) functions.

Before last night's meeting, I spoke with Majority Leader Frank Morris, III; one of my favorite councilpersons in terms of him being a curmudgeonly political/government leader.

The topic?

Who is to blame for the hole Canton finds itself in.

It seemed to me that he was focusing on past mayors in "the blame game" talk.

"Well," I said "do you think Council has any part of the blame?"

Begrudgingly, he agreed that Councils have been partially to blame.

But only about 40% (the converse of my recollection that he put 60% of the blame on past city mayors).

The Stark County Political Report believes and blogs prolifically that the public should remember the names and deeds of those in the public sector have failed us.

So The Report compiled this list of former council members going back to about 1968.

There have been some 100 councilpersons who have served in Canton City Council going back for nearly 40 years.

Obviously, one cannot included Council-at-Large Thomas Harmon and Ward 3 councilman Jason Scaglione (both newly elected in November, 2015) as being part of the the problem.

But the list does include names of councilpersons still on council and a number of former mayors as well as the current mayor (Bernabei) and Deputy Mayor Fonda Williams.

Moreover, it includes the father of recently defeated mayor William J. Healy, II who himself aspired to be mayor but lost to Richard Watkins in 1999.



 And here is list of mayors going back to 1964.


These lists clearly constitute a "We Have Met the Enemy and He/She is Us," accounting to the Canton general public, no?

It seems that Morris' demarcation is not valid separation of categories of who is to blame.

The lesson of past failures of Canton legislators/mayors to protect/enhance the infrastructure of the city is that with the adoption of the comprehensive plan by a unanimous vote of council, Cantonians should require periodic accountings of taxpayer funds invested in plan and what the investment yielded in terms of quantifiable results.


(Councilpersons Speaking in Favor of Comprehensive Plan)

Mayor Bernabei has a very dicey problem on his hands in seeing to it that accountable structures of implementation of the plan are created.



In the past the mayor has endorsed the plan which endorsement he reiterated last night as seen in the foregoing video.

The SCPR thinks that the Canton public should look to him to ensure that things are done correctly in the sense that the structures of administration are productively functional and that the results are reported in an official "for the general public" accountability session on a minimum annual basis.

It is all well and good for Mayor Bernabei to include council members and other factors in the construction of the mechanisms implementing and administrating general fund taxpayer dollars invested in to the plan, but be it himself or a successor mayor, the "buck must stop" at the mayor's office.

Ward 5 councilman Kevin Fisher said last night that his vote was his most important in his time as a councilperson as seen in the video posted above.

And, it may be.  But he has a lot of undoing of harm to do before he can be satisfied that he is a net positive factor on council.

As far as the SCPR, he is digging himself out of a political hole of having played (LINK) political games with a few other councilpersons in trying to implant a poison pill in the ability a persons to run for and Cantonians to vote on the creation of a Canton Charter Commission.


He bears primary responsibility along with his union business agent friend David Kirven of Pipefitters and Plumbers Local #94 and the use of Jefferson-Jackson Democratic funds ($500) to help defeat the charter issue.

Fisher had better hope that more positive things come along for him to support as a councilman so that he can undo the damage that The Report thinks he and Kirven orchestrated in denying future councils and administrations the flexibility needed to adjust to the constantly changing need to provide effective governance.

Kudos to Councilwoman Chris Smith on her turnabout on the comprehensive plan.

All Cantonians have heard so far is talk.

It is now time for action AND accountability in the context of meaningful investment over a reasonable, sustainable period of time.

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

PART 1: THE COST OF INEFFECTIVE "CANTON" LEADERSHIP OVER DECADES? $460,000 MM OR NEARLY 1/2 BILLION!

UPDATED:  WEDNESDAY AT 6:00 AM



VIDEOS

CANTON PLANNING COMMISSION
ROLL CALL
ON ADOPTING COMPREHENSIVE PLAN

==============================

MEMBER DAVID KAMINSKI
MOTION TO ADOPT

 ==============================

CZB PRINCIPAL CHARLES BUKI
ON TIMELINE FROM
2012 RFQ TO 02292015 

============================== 

Yesterday late afternoon was the beginning of the end story for the proud city of Canton, Ohio.

The only question is:  What will the end story be?

Will Canton sink into oblivion and unrecoverable despair as seemingly Flint, Michigan has done.

Or will finally gets it act together and begin a long, tortuous road to recover at the cost of 460,000 millions of dollars?

Charles Buki of CZB Consulting was frank and direct in pointing his finger at former leadership of the City of Canton as being the reason that Canton has decayed since the 1950s

(SCPR Note:  Documents in this blog extracted from the February 20th published "Comprehensive Plan - City of Canton UNLESS otherwise noted)

The most telling document:


In this blog, The Stark County Political Report will take readers on a video trip (short, easily digestible video clips) through Buki's presentation so that all Cantonians can see for themselves the core history of why Canton is where it is in terms of being a depressed city and the harsh realities that present Cantonians and likely the city's future generations will have to face up to if the city is to recover her former greatness.

My goal with this blog is to make it a seminal document/video documentary on Canton's Comprehensive Plan  in terms of being a reference point as Canton's current generation of leaders move forward to implement the Comprehensive Plan as surely Canton City Council will ultimately adopt on the heels of the Canton Planning Commission having done yesterday.


Those present at yesterday's special Canton Planning Commission (CPC) meeting applauded (see video [1:18 in duration] of the vote and applause below) as the roll call by member David Kaminski (former Repository editor and now a Canton Regional Chamber of Commerce official) resulted in a unanimous approval of moving forward with the plan as a recommendation to Canton City Council (CCC).



And here is a video (7:07) of Kaminski's motion and the ensuing discussion:



Though I was born and raised in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, I do have a family connection to Canton, Ohio.

My maternal grandfather, Howard S. Weaver, worked for the-then Norfolk & Western Railroad (out of its Roanoke, Virginia base) during my mother's girlhood which ranged through the 1910 through 1925 era and I can remember of her child of her telling tales of Howard's travels as the employee of the N&W.

One of his very favorite cities in his travels was Canton, Ohio as he was impressed with the robust nature of life in Canton.

Consequently, I felt a special connection to Canton when I was employed as a lawyer for the Stark County Legal Aid Society in 1974.  I worked in Canton day-in, day-out for five years.  Moreover, even from the site of my private practice law office and home (Uniontown, Lake Township) I was a frequenter of Canton, Ohio for more than 40 years.  As a blogger since March, 2008, I have provided Cantonians with thorough and extensive coverage of Canton city government.

It was gratifying (from my days at Stark County Legal Aid, SCLAS) to see Canton assistant law director Thomas Burns at the table of the Canton Planning Commission as the commission's legal counsel.

Tom was one of a number of illustrious attorneys (including now deceased former Stark County prosecutor and Stark County Probate Court judge Robert Horowitz) with whom I served on the staff at the SCLAS.

Obviously therefore I have been a first hand witness to the decline of Canton over the 40 years.

And it is now gratifying through this blog to be in a position to prod current Canton/Stark County leadership to step-up-to-the-plate and begin the process of recovering from the 60, 70 years of decline.

It is likely that the process of recovery will take the better part of 50 years going forward.

And it will entail current proven effective leaders like Canton mayor Thomas M. Bernabei and Stark County auditor Alan Harold to take on a project of developing a higher quality of bank of leadership than currently exists in Canton/Stark County.

A STEP BACK FROM PASSAGE TO THE BUKI (CZB) PRESENTATION

BEFORE THE CANTON PLANNING COMMISSION

Buki's Background


In looking into the background of CZB principal Charles Buki, it did my heart good to see that he has a personal background in blogging.

I wonder how man planning commission members and Canton council members and staff of the mayor's administration (including Healy's and, of course, that of new the new mayor Thomas Bernabei) have done their homework to determine whether or not Buki and his CZB group has a viewpoint and track record of urban planning successes before making the decision to adopt the CZB generated comprehensive plan.

A good start is with the above-reference blog (LINK) that he last wrote on March 1, 2013; three years ago today which includes the following topics:

  
Other links:
And, for sure, if they haven't already (which one would assume they have inasmuch as Canton has spent $350,000 of Canton taxpayer dollars with CZB) somebody on council and or in the administration ought to be calling present and past customers of CZB LLC before Canton council adopts the CZB generated plan.

Additionally, before Canton council adopts the Comprehensive Plan, it needs to as part of the adoption build into the adoption structures of plan implementation that it will be implement 100%; no matter how long it takes and no matter how many modifications of the plan are made.

As will seen in the video clips provided in this blog, Buki cites instance, after instance after instance in which cities have not "fully" implemented the plan.

Well!  How can city fairly evaluate the likes of CZB if council and the administration have not fully implemented the plan?

VIDEO HIGHLIGHTS WITH SCPR COMMENTARY
ON
BUKI'S PRESENTATION TO THE CANTON PLANNING COMMISSION

TIMELINE VIDEO - BUKI (4:20)

In the following video, after being introduced by Mayor Bernabei and Deputy Mayor Fonda Williams, CZB principal Charles Buki details the timeline in summary fashion from the time that Canton City Council authorized the Healy administration to publish a RFQ (Request for Quote) in 2012 through yesterday (February 29, 2016).


    The next noteworthy part of Buki's presentations as far as the SCPR is concerned was his general description of the parameters within which the plan was devised.

    In the following video it is obvious that he is acutely aware of the severe financial limitations that Canton presently has in implementing the plan.  (Video length:  1:38)


    Monday, November 10, 2014

    A HOLDING THEM ACCOUNTABLE SERIES: CANTON'S CITYWIDE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN



    The Canton Citywide Comprehensive Plan (CCP) meetings are over.

    Now it is time to think about holding Canton's city government officials and elected politicians accountable for "implementing" it when it comes down from CZB, LLC next spring.


    Its unveiling will likely take place during the lead up to the 2015 primary election season.

    As only The Stark County Political Report is wont to do with regularity and consistency among Stark County's media, in the wake of Stark County government officials introducing this or that plan; The Report follows up on the rhetoric to assess whether or not any such plan is likely to bear any fruit.

    Stark County and political subdivision government has a graveyard full of various "quick fix" schemes for this or that ill that plagues countywide and local government.

    When in April Council authorized the CCP - a well over one-quarter-of-a-million-dollar Canton taxpayer financed expenditure  - there were councilpersons with reservations, to wit:

    - Frank Morris, III (Ward 9),
    - James Babcock, (At-Large),
    - Richard Hart, (At-Large),
    - Bill Smuckler, (At-Large)

    Undoubtedly, all four will be in sync with the SCPR in tracking the taxpayer dollars spent by a city that has precious few discretionary dollars to spend.

    The base question?

    Whether or not the CCP is just "so much hot air" designed to deflect attention from a largely failed two term city administration (the Healy administration) sprung on Cantonians so that William J. Healy, II can get elected a third time.

    Morris, in particular, the SCPR thinks should be paid a lot of attention to by Cantonians as "a bellweather critic" on the issue of whether or not the CCP "is for real" and "probably will" produce long term "we're on our way back" results for Canton.



    He is a political curmudgeon to be sure.

    But in the judgment of the SCPR, Morris is the  most reliable councilperson in terms of showing The Report that he is willing to "cut through the crap" and "call a spade a spade" when the realities command such.

    One might object that the $350,000 Canton city taxpayer-paid-for-plan has not yet been formulated or published and will not be shared with Cantonians until March, 2015.

    The SCPR's response?

    Plenty is already known from the series of meetings as to what ails Canton and what needs to be fixed and "time's 'a wastin'" on getting on coming up with solutions.


    This series will serve as primary resource for Cantonians to know about the Canton Comprehensive Plan; A to Z.

    A secondary purpose if this series is to inform Canton voters who is doing what to bring about a revitalized Canton as a indication as to whether or not those elected officials who are currently in place deserve to be continued in office.

    Here is a catalog of prior SCPR blogs which have dealt with the CCP from the idea stage to where it is now.

    Besides "specific to the point" SCPR blogs on the CCP, there are other city of Canton developments that The Report considers "to be in the manner of identifying and correcting fundamental flaws in Canton recovering a portion of her former glory.

    These include:  
    • (process) (negative)
      • Lowest voter turnout in Stark County (Councilwoman Chris Smith, 11% in precinct 4F) in the recently concluded November 4, 2014 general election
      • Of the 16 Stark County precincts voting 20% or less, Canton precincts included:
        • Councilwoman Chris Smith's Ward 4 at four,
        • Councilman Tom West's Ward 2 at four,
        • Councilman Greg Hawk's Ward 1 at two,
        • Councilman Fisher's Ward 5 at one, and
        • Councilman Morris' Ward 9 at one
    It is good news that Ward 3 councilman Jim Griffin will not be seeking a new term as councilman. While Griffin is a terrific guy at the personal level, he is not the type of councilperson that Canton needs going forward.
    It is bad news that former Canton Municipal Court clerk of courts Tom Harmon (also former Stark County commissioner [appointed]) says he has taken out petitions to run for council at large.

    He, as a matter of public record:
    • has indication of personal problems to deal with, 
    • is "a has been" politician 
    who as commissioner was very unimpressive in dealing with the county's serious financial problems at the time.

    Many expect Mary Cirelli, a long time council person, former state representative and county commissioner to seek a return to a council-at-large position.

    Again, the SCPR views Cirelli (like Griffin) as a terrific individual at the personal level, but not equipped to provide what Canton City Council needs of a council person.

    The SCPR discourages her of the notion of seeking to return to council.

    As readers of the SCPR know, The Report takes citizen involvement in their governments to be a critical part of us having a healthy democratic-republic.

    On that score, Wards 2 and 4 are far and away the worst in the city.

    The Report thinks that all public officials need to do more to develop ways and means to impress upon citizens their obligation to engage government officials and government itself.

    At the base level of our system of government is the absolutely elementary level of citizen participation in casting the ballot.

    Grassroots elected officials (e.g. city council members, township trustees and the like) should be the vanguard of GOTV (getting out the vote) irrespective of an individual citizen's political bias.

    Stark County as a whole has a problem.

    Only 41% voted in the November 4th election.

    In 2010 (like 2014, a gubernatorial election year) 48% voted in Stark County.
    It is clear that base level politicians are not getting the job done in finding ways to interest their constituents in exercising the franchise.

    The most grievous examples come out of Canton's Wards 2 and 4.


    In the May, 2014, Councilwoman Smith had a precinct that voted a disgraceful 2.03%


    Last Tuesday, 13.3% of Ward 4B's voters voted.

    Wow!, no?

    Smith might want to brag that between the primary and the general Precinct 4B increased over 600%.

    On the other hand, she might want to hide somewhere?

    When you're talking an increase from 2.03% to 13.38%; a 600% increase is not all that impressive, no?

    The low voter turnout overall in Wards 2 and 4 which are wards that have the bulk of Canton's 40% plus poverty rate suggests to the SCPR that West and Smith are highly ineffective leaders.


    But that did not keep them from seeking leadership positions in Canton's government in the Democratic caucuses of December, 2013.

    West challenged Morris for being majority leader. Smith, when it was apparent that West was "destined for failure" was, the SCPR is told,  a compromise for assistant majority leader.

    As the new term of council convened in early 2014, West got council hung up on the leadership question to the point that council could do very little else for several weeks.

    Could the voting/economic data and belaboring the leadership question suggest that West (10 years on council) and Smith (6 years on council) mode of leadership is not working and that their "doing what they always done" is a significant part of Canton's chronic problems and that they are unlikely to be coming up with any solutions?

    Maybe the CCP information gathering and planning process will prompt them and other marginal Canton leaders to rethink their role in Canton city government?

    Let's hope!

    In the meantime, readers of the SCPR can depend on The Report to hold Canton City officials' "feet to the fire!"

    Political rhetoric is out.

    Getting results is all that counts, if Canton is to turn things around.

    Is the CCP the answer?

    Vetting and actual "productive" implementation will "tell the tale!"

    Monday, October 6, 2014

    (VIDEOS) CANTON COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: GOING NOWHERE?



    VIDEOS

    Councilman/Majority Leader
    Frank Morris, II
    April 28, 2014 

    Morris
    on
    October 2, 2014

    Citizen Sandy Reo
    October 2, 2014

    Ward 1
    Councilman Greg Hawk
    October 2, 2014

    Ward 7
    Councilman John Mariol
    October 2, 2014

    Councilman at Large
    Bill Smuckler
    October 2, 2014

    On Thursday last, Ward 9 councilman and Canton City Council majority leader Frank Morris, III hosted a series of community meetings designed to acquaint Cantonians with Canton's Comprehensive Plan.



    Announced by Canton mayor William J. Healy, II in his "State of the City" Address on April 2, 2014 and authorized/endowed by Canton City Council to the tune of $350,000 to hire a consulting firm, "the plan" does have its skeptics.

    Council on April 28th did vote to finance the plan on a 7 to 4 vote.  (Morris, Babcock, Hart and Smuckler voting "no")

    The foremost "negative" is Morris.

    Here is Morris on the 28th.



    Here is Morris last Thursday evening at Schreiber Elementary School:



    Also chiming in on the plan were:

    CITIZEN SANDY REO (WARD 9)



    WARD 1 COUNCILMAN GREG HAWK



    WARD 7 COUNCILMAN JOHN MARIOL



    CITYWIDE COUNCILMAN BILL SMUCKLER



    The SCPR attended the first Canton Comprehensive Plan meeting in Edmond Mack's Ward 8, (September 16) and midway-point meeting last Thursday and contemplates attending the finale in Kevin Fisher's Ward 5 on October 16th at the J. Babe Stern Center.

    The "elephant in the room" question is whether or not the Canton Comprehensive Plan has "a snowball's chance in Hell" of ever being implemented.

    Because Canton officialdom is mired in despair over the decades decline of the Hall of Fame city, an implemented Canton Comprehensive Plan is viewed by some on council as Canton's last chance at resurrecting this once proud city.

    The SCPR gets the impression from Councilman Morris that he views the plan as much hogwash and he will be holding the Healy administration accountable for wasting $350,000 of taxpayer money if all the plan proves to be is a publicity stunt of sorts.

    One Cantonian (Citizen Cantonian) has asked what the SCPR thinks is a very good question:  If a plan is constructed from citizen input from the city's nine wards, where is the money coming from to implement it?

    The SCPR is told that within the next week or two, the Healy administration will be sending legislation to council for passage with respect to generating some $15 million to $17 million in bond money to help finance various projects throughout the city in a kind of a "pre-plan:  Canton Comprehensive Plan."

    Well, a second question has to be:  If it is taking $15 million to $17 million to "pre-plan" plus millions more as Canton's share of the Mahoning Road and 12th Street corridor projects, where in "God's little green acre of Canton, Ohio" are the millions upon millions to come from - that, undoubtedly, will be needed - to fund Canton's "in the works" Comprehensive Plan?

    The Report is told that various council members (Ward one's Greg Hawk [finance committee chair], Ward seven's John Mariol and Morris) have been involved in discussions with the mayor regarding "how much" and for "what uses" will the contemplated bond issue defined.

    Here is a speculated preliminary list:

    1.  $5,000,000.00    Hall of Fame project.

    2.  $2,000,000.00   Onesta Loan

    3.  $2,000,000.00   Chamber Downtown Project (The Kresge Lot)  Amphitheater I believe.

    4.  $2,000,000.00   New Roofs (Civic Center, Sears building etc.)

    5.  $2,000,000.00   City share of demolitions cost.

    6.  $2,000,000.00   Street Department new building and truck wash.

    And The Report is told that the Healy administration is working on a sub-plan to sell the Sears building which houses various city offices and relocate them in substitute purchased alternative site; namely, The Canton Jewish Center on 25th Street.

    The point being that if the Sears/Jewish Center story is accurate (which surely will require "above and beyond" revenues from the sale of Sears) to get The Jewish Center rehabbed and ready for Canton government's use.

    Again, if this report proves to be well-founded, you have a $15 million to $17 million bond fund expenditure, you have millions of city money going into Mahoning/12th Street, and - perhaps - money going into rehabbing the Jewish Center; the question compounded comes out:  Where is the money going to come from for implementing a Canton Comprehensive Plan.

    The SCPR thinks Citizen Cantonian is asking the correct questions about the funding of a Canton Comprehensive Plan.

    The SCPR thinks Frank Morris is not being a "doom and gloom" councilman in his consistent expressions of skepticism of about the practicality, reliability and viability of the much touted Canton Comprehensive Plan.

    The SCPR thinks that Mayor Healy and his planning gurus need to start answering those questions.

    For now, the administration should be projecting a "within our 'maximum' capability" skeletal capital needs budget that Canton finances and projected taxpayer support will allow for.

    The Report thinks the planners need to know Canton's "reality-based" financial capability before coming down with a plan.

    The only thing worse than having no plan at all, is to have a "pie-in-the-sky" plan that has no chance of complete implementation.

    The SCPR thinks such is what concerns Frank Morris.

    Though Morris' views do not appear to be popular among his peers, they would be wise to pay attention to his skepticism and insist that any Canton Comprehensive Plan be fundable and therefore doable!