Showing posts with label Curtis Werren. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Curtis Werren. Show all posts

Friday, October 30, 2015

GUARDADO & WERREN PRESENT POLTICOS AS "OUR COMMUNTY LEADERS" AND "YOUR STARK COUNTY TEAM. REALLY?



A SCPR ANALYSIS OF

GUARDADO & WERREN CAMPAIGN FLIERS

WHICH

JUST ARRIVED IN THE MAIL

WHO WILL WIN?

The Guardado/Werren for Canton Municipal Court judge match up may be the hardest race to call in all of the Stark County political subdivision campaigns in this election cycle.

The outcome in this election "depends on" a number of factors materializing or not materializing.

And there are plenty of political ironies at play at this race.

For example, one of Guardado's key supporters is Stark County commissioner Thomas M. Bernabei who is, as any politically "aware" Stark Countian knows, is running as an "independent" (as of May 4, 2015) against Democratic incumbent mayor William J. Healy, II who is seeking a third term.

Healy, II supported Angela Alexander in the Democratic primary in May whereas Bernabei (not yet switched from being a long time Democratic elected to office many times as a Democrat to being a political "independent") supported Guardado and was up until a few days before May 4th.

If Guardado is to win in the Canton Municipal Court District:


She will have do to exceptionally well in Canton itself.

Otherwise, she loses.

One of the problems with Guardado doing exceptionally well in Canton is that a good part of "independent" Bernabei's support is coming from Republicans who have no candidate in next Tuesday's face off.

The Report figures Bernabei to win with relative ease because he likely will take about one-half the Democratic vote (especially in Wards 7, 8 and 9) and will get nearly every Republican vote.

And, of course, it is common political knowledge that Republicans do and likely will in the Healy/Bernabei race vote in significantly higher percentages than do Democrats.

However, there will be no coattails advantage for Guardado in having a close association with her former campaign treasurer.

Republicans, to the degree the turnout to vote, will switch from Bernabei to Republican Werren in a nano-second.

The strategy that each Guardado and Werren are playing out is assuming that their respective loyal political party voters will turn out in greater numbers that the opponent's.

POLITICAL PARTY TIES EMPHASIZED IN A JUDICIAL RACE?

That partisan political party politics is playing such key role in a judicial race should be dismaying to voters in the Canton Municipal Court District.

After all, the official line is that judges are above politics in their administration of justice.

But with the campaign flyers that each side put out within the past few days emphasizing their respective political party ties, one has to question whether or not Guardado and Werren could administer justice should one of the listed politicos in their respective flyers run afoul of the Stark County system of justice and end up appearing before a Judge Guardado (in the case of the Democratic politicos) or Judge Werren (in the case of the Republican politicos).

Of course, the obvious answer is that such a scenario would not unfold because either would recuse her/himself and have another judge hear the case.

Even it there is a workaround, it is alarming the degree to which judicial candidates immerse themselves in partisan politics in terms of it undermining the general public's confidence in the integrity of our system of justice and not just off somewhere else but right hear in Stark County, Ohio.

DISSECTING THE FLYERS IN THE CONTEXT OF GUARDADO & WARREN BECOMING THE NOMINEES OF THEIR POLITICAL PARTIES

In that vein of interest, the SCPR dissects the flyers referred to above.

Note:  At the end of the blog the entire flyer of each candidate is to be seen.

There are two notable "political" happenings in the 2015 cycle political history of both candidates.

WERREN

Werren for the second time got a political appointment from Republican governor John Kasich (see LINK for the history).  He did have a competitor (who even went so far as to take out Board of Elections petitions for the May 5, 2015 Republican primary) for the appointment, but as the SCPR looks back it is apparent that it was Werren all the way with the governor.

A SCPR blog from the June, 2013 first appointment:


So is it surprising that in the flyer mailed out in support of his second candidacy for The Report, in analyzing it, to see this?


Of course, not.

The word is that Werren did do a credible job in his first appointment as a Stark County Court of Common Pleas judge, but not good enough in the judgement of Stark County voters to be retained as a judge.

Upstart Democrat (upstart in terms of taking on a incumbent judge) Chryssa Hartnett convinced voters that her time in the Stark County criminal justice system as a county prosecutor was more impressive than a man who up until he was appointed judge was most recently the president of the Canton chapter of the American Red Cross and not a practicing attorney.

Such fits perfectly with the SCPR's theme that Werren would not be a person ever heard of - but for - his Republican Party political connections through his father John Werren.

Kasich:  "I work hard to appoint the best possible Judges."

Really?

Well,  Democrat Hartnett asked Kasich to appoint her.

Of course, her's was a pipe dream.  But in appying she showed that the governor is all about politics, no matter his "the best possible" rhetoric.

It took the Stark County voting public to override what was clearly a Kasich political loyalist decision.

After all, as Werren's wife Stephanie (a Ward 3 North Canton councilwoman) was heard to say in apparent bitterness after husband Curt lost to Hartnett:  (paraphrase)  "But she already has a job, it's not fair."

Fair?

What's fair about somebody getting a political appointment based on a pedigree of political party loyalty?

GUARDADO

Guardado is pretty much a creature of politics, too.  Only not to the degree Werren is in The Report's opinion.


Guardado faced a stiff primary election challenge in May against Stark County native Angela Alexander who, unfortunately, for purposes of that election had to rely on having had most of her distinguished career in Summit County.


Man oh man! did the bigs (e.g. the Giavasis brothers and former chairman Randy Gonzalez and his son Kody) in the "organized" Stark County Democratic Party work Alexander over.

They had assured Alexander that the official Dems would stay out of the primary and she would have an opportunity to run on her merits.

That did not happen.

For the SCPR's money, Alexander is vastly superior in terms of legal experience which would have parlayed into her being a much better judge than wither Guardado or Werren.

A HISTORY OF A PRIOR STARK COUNTY JUDICIAL APPOINTEE

As the SCPR has been saying for years, quality of candidates appears to be happenstance with both mainline political parties.

One need look no further than Stark County Court of Common Pleas, Probate Division judge Dixie Park to understand the legal mayhem unsuspecting day-in, day-out Stark Countians may suffer at the hands of a person who got her job as a judge by the hand of the Ohio Republican Party and then Republican governor Bob Taft.

One consequence of her going unconstitutional (LINK) was that a everyday Stark Countian unjustly spent over one week in the Stark County jail.

Of course, that indignity was visited upon an ordinary citizen.

Not the relative, friend or acquaintance of some influential public official.

So the typical answer:  "stuff happens!"


Park who seemingly has unlimited campaign finances at her beck and call, the SCPR thinks, has embarrassed herself in being overturned on Constitutional law abridgments on several occasions within the past several years.

One has to wonder whether or not there isn't a bevy of administration of just shortcomings that have gone publicly unnoticed?

Just on the instances cited in the linked to blog, ne would think that Republicans from Kasich on down to the Stark County Republican Party chairman would want this woman off the bench as being a telling and continuing indictment of the political party appointment process for judicial appointments.  Especially judicial appointments.

Think maybe just maybe the contending for an appointment process ought to have as the main criterion: "I am the least politically connected" rather than the real politik, "I am so and so in the Stark County political world?"

That is if the fair and impartial administration of justice is a real goal and not some kind of legal fiction, no?

One Republican who does deserve credit for quelling Park's appetite to run for a spot on the 5th District Court of Appeals is Republican David Gormley of Delaware County.

Stark County Republican Party connected officials, present and past including judges and attorneys except for Craig Conley and Jeff Jakmides sit by and do nothing to encourage Park to step aside.

POLITICAL FALLOUT & REVERBERATIONS

The public is getting wiser by the day to "organized" Dems and Republicans and are more apt than ever to opt for anybody but a loyalist Democrat or Republican if given a choice.

Recently, the SCPR checked with John Alexander (Angela's husband).  He tells yours truly that Angela is supporting Guardado but is not taking much of role in the campaign.

And Guardado like Werren is playing to her strength.  Not, in the opinion of the SCPR her magnificent credentials to be a judge.  But, rather, her political connections.

Sorry state of affairs and implications for the quality of the bench in the Canton Municipal Court District insofar as The Report is concerned.

It is interesting that Hartville police chief Larry Dordea is weighing in so prominently for Werren in what the SCPR thinks as being a factor of political party loyalty when he himself was thrown under the Democratic Bus George T. Maier/Johnnie A. Maier, Jr with merely a whimper coming from some of the very same Republicans who are pictured standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Werren in the picture below.


Had the key Stark County officials pictured below (except for Alex Zumbar who was Dordea's treasurer) and Stark County Republican Party officialdom stepped forward much stronger for Dordea, he would be Stark County sheriff today and The Report thinks Stark County's sheriff's department of government be much less politicized than it currently is.

The Report has thought and written Dordea to be several notches above - in character - over Geroge T. Maier.  Moreover, yours truly has written extensively on what appears to be Maier's wholesale politicization (LINK) of the Stark County sheriff's office.


Maybe this is too much of a leap, but it could be that Dordea as evidenced by his endorsement of Werren is as nearly infected with excessive partisanism as are others that The Report writes about?

Dordea's endorsement is in the guise of being a law enforcement official, but is that really the basis of the endorsement?

The Report suspects the Dordea endorsement is more borne of political affiliation than of Werren being the best choice in the interest of having effective Canton Municipal Court District law enforcement.

As such, his involvement in the Werren support group is a major disappointment.

DEMS & REPUBLICANS TAKE TOO MUCH ON THEMSELVES

One final point that the SCPR advances in this blog.

It is interesting how in each respective flyer an attempt is made to pass off supporting politicos as being the equivalent of  "our community leaders" and "your Stark County team."  (emphasis added)

Our?

Your?

You've got to be kidding Werren and Guardado, no?


Readers will note in looking closely at the graphics offered that the SCPR x'd out the "our" and "your" and substituted the proper terminology, to wit:  Guardado's "our" equals loyal Democratic Party elected officials; Werren's "your" equals loyal Republican Party elected officials.

That's the truth of the matter!

Political party first and foremost.

There have to be plenty of lawyers among Stark County's bar that are more qualified to be judge than the politically connected Werren and Guardado, no?

But therein lies the rub.

Generally, one does not get to be a  judge in Stark County unless one is politically connected.

While Stark sitting judges like to present themselves as being the best in terms of mental, legal acuity and temperament; the SCPR thinks the odds are against such actually being the case given the rank degree of politics involved in getting to be a judge in the first place.

And Stark County is particular seems to be a haven for a lack of competition between qualified candidates in both political parties competing on the merits of their experience and inherent wisdom as human beings for judicial posts.

Angela Alexander marveled in a campaign Q&A at the Dems' party headquarters at the lack of competition for judgeships in Stark County as compared to Summit County.

In Summit County, there are many vigorous judicial competitions within the political party structure itself.

But not in Stark County.

For the SCPR, the Canton Municipal Court District voters (one of whom is yours truly) have only be given the choice of picking our poison in terms of one political party connected person as against another.

Doesn't it tempt one to opt out of the election process altogether or have the option a la the following graphic on the Healy/Perez May 5, 2015 Democratic primary race?  (LINK)

The Report thinks Healy and Perez are both shop worn politicos who, if they differ at all, only do so in the degree of how politically manipulative they are.


Actually, opting out is not an option for yours truly.

But there have been quite a few election contests over some 50 years of voting that yours truly has declined to exercise a similitude of a "Hobson's choice."

It's fine for folks including elected officials to be passionate about their political party affiliations.

But not to the point of damaging the institutions of government by the endorsement of and appointment of people whose major qualification being politically connected.

For the SCPR it is satisfying in terms of politics coming back to haunt appointing officials as seemingly was the case recently with Massillon mayor Kathy Catazaro-Perry.

Politics is a necessary evil for our system of government, but it can be made less evil and damaging of the public interest if Republcan and Democratic were to develop a finely honed quality called:  DISCERNMENT!

THE FULL FLYERS

GUARDADO



WERREN



Wednesday, January 7, 2015

WILL CURT WERREN GET THE CHANCE TO BE "A TWO TIME LOSER?



The SCPR has indication that there was talk among "organized" Stark County Republicans that it would be pointless to recommend Curtis Werren to Republican governor John Kasich for appointment to Canton Municipal Court seat vacated on November 30, 2014 by Republican judge Stephen Belden.

Really?

Why not?

Because it is believed that the governor will not "second appoint" someone to an elective office when that person failed to hold the first appointed office in the election following on the heels of the appointment.

If that take on the governor is accurate, then, as the SCPR sees it, the Republicans are "between a rock and a hard place."

Really?

Why?

Because the Republicans best chance to retain the former Belden seat as a Republican-held seat is with Curtis Werren.

The other "recommended for appointment" candidate; namely, Aaron Kovalchik has virtually no chance to defeat the presumptive Democratic nominee Kristen Guardado come November, 2015.

In a SCPR analysis of the loser race of Werren's against Chryssa Hartnett (Stark County Court of Common Pleas; replacing V. Lee Sinclair to which Werren was appointed in July, 2013), Werren won by some 1,000 votes, more or less, over Harnett.

So wouldn't that make him the "odds on favorite" to defeat any Democratic opponent?

Not in the SCPR analysis, if Guardado get through the Democratic primary.

And it is hard to imagine that she will not.

Her prospective opponents include:

  • a Stark Countian (Angela Alexander) who has practiced law in Summit County for most of if not all of her career as a lawyer.
  • a "shop-worn" Democrat (E.E. Wise, Jr) who has, of late, been an administrator (North Canton) who like Werren appears to be desperate to find a job as a judge.
    • Wise has run and lost for Stark County Probate Court judge and the 5th District Court of Appeals,
      • However, The Report is being told that he is waffling on whether or not to stay in the Democratic primary
Guardado is the most experienced and the SCPR thinks most merited candidate to succeed Judge Belden.  Of particular note, her extensive work in the area of dealing with domestic violence cases which is a large part of Canton Municipal Court work.

And the SCPR is told that she will have all the financial resources she needs to wage a first-rate campaign against any Republican appointed by Kasich.

She wisely has touched base with "the powers that be" within the "organized" Stark County Party and thereby likely endeared herself to them.

And, of course, her boss is the immensely popular, well-known, and highly respected Canton law director Joseph Martuccio is in her corner.


One can safely bet will he will be going all out in support of Guardado's quest to give Stark Democrats majority control of the Canton Municipal Court bench.

And he will likely will be running unopposed on the November, 2015 ballot.

Notwithstanding the talk among local Republicans that Kasich is loathe to 2nd appoint a person who did not retain the first appointed office, the SCPR thinks as between Werren and Kovalchik, the only hope for the Republicans to hold on to the Belden slot will be for him to violate the "supposed" rule he has for giving the likes of Werren "a second bite at the Apple."

The Report thinks the Republican lose either way.

At least with Werren, they have a fighting chance.

It is interesting to note that Kovalchik is reported in local media has pledging to support Werren if Kashich appoints the former Common Pleas Court judge.

However, there is no reported such pledge coming from Werren.

So does this mean that should Kovalchik get the Kasich appointment that he will face primary opposition from Werren who has taken out petitions?

One would think that Kovalchik will be taking out petitions of his own any day now.

For if he fails to do so before the filing deadline in early February and he gets the appointment post-filing-deadline then he would only serve until the results of the November, 2015 election are certified.

Now that would be something, wouldn't it?

And, for Kovalchik, it would be a splendid turn of events if he is the appointed.

Right now, nobody outside the legal community knows who he is.  A Republican Party primary fight would change all that.

And there couldn't be a greater contrast.

Werren the quintessential nabob, establishment and privileged Republican against a more Lincolnesque - former public defender - "I connect with everyday people" Republican.

What a godsend that would be for The Stark County Political Report.

Friday, November 21, 2014

A "SPECIAL" EDITION OF THE SCPR BLOG: HOW THE PROVISIONALS & ABSENTEES PLAYED OUT IN HARTNETT'S VICTORY OVER WERREN



'FINAL" 
UPDATE "SUNDAY"  11/23/2014 - "HIGH NOON"

SPREADSHEETS PUBLISHED

'CLICK ON GRAPHICS TO ENLARGE'

ALLIANCE
=========================
BETHLEHEM TOWNSHIP
=========================
CANAL FULTON
=========================
CANTON CITY
=========================
CANTON TOWNSHIP
=========================
JACKSON TOWNSHIP
=========================
LAKE TOWNSHIP
INCLUDES
HARTVILLE
=========================
LAWRENCE TOWNSHIP
=========================
LEXINGTON TOWNSHIP
=========================
LOUISVILLE
========================
MARLBORO TOWNSHIP
========================
MASSILLON
========================
MYERS LAKE & NAVARRE
========================
NIMISHILLEN TOWNSHIP
========================
NORTH CANTON
========================
OSNABURG TOWNSHIP
INCLUDES
 (EAST CANTON)
========================
PARIS TOWNSHIP - MINERVA
========================
PERRY TOWNSHIP
========================
PIKE TOWNSHIP
INCLUDING
EAST SPARTA
========================
PLAIN TOWNSHIP
========================
SANDY TOWNSHIP 
 MAGNOLIA
WAYNESBURG
========================
SUGARCREEK TOWNSHIP
BREWSTER
========================
TUSCARAWAS TOWNSHIP
========================
WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP

The results are in.

After the provisional ballots and "late" arriving but postmarked on or before November 4, 2014 absentee ballots have been counted and certified as official numbers, as the SCPR predicted, Democrat Chryssa Hartnett pulled off a pretty amazing defeat of Republican Curtis Werren for Stark County Court of Common Pleas judge for the unexpired term of V. Lee Sinclair (a Republican himself).


In year when the lead of the Republican ticket (Republican incumbent governor John Kasich) won by over 37,000 votes in Stark County, a Democrat wins over an incumbent though "appointed" Republican.

Simply amazing.

Just an aside, but the Stark County Republican Party leadership has some "soul searching to do" in having Werren and Republican sheriff candidate Larry Dordea lose in an overwhelming Republican year.

Being the "number cruncher" the SCPR is, The Report has embarked on a "weekend project" of going through each and every precinct of Stark County's 284 precincts to show Stark County voters exactly where Hartnett overwhelmed Werren to gain 101 more votes of the provisionals and late arriving absentees to increase her "unofficial" election day tally from 29 votes to 131.

That is the "official" and certified count.

There will be a recount, but there is plenty of margin for Hartnett to offset any glitches that may surface.

Again, simply amazing!

The SCPR is pleased to have been a leading communicator of the greater degree of qualification that Hartnett possessed over Werren.

Nothing against Werren, but he did play the political game in getting the appointment.

It is refreshing to see merit win.

ALLIANCE

Starting off with Alliance.


In Alliance 69 uncounted "potential" votes remained after election night.

Of the 69 uncounteds 22 were disqualified for one reason or another "unanimously" by the two Democrats (Sherer, Jr and Ferruccio) and two Republicans (Braden and Cline), all of whom are political appointees by their respective political parties.

In Alliance alone, Hartnett picked up 15 votes to make her margin increase from 29 to 44.

Werren was in real trouble coming out of Alliance.  He wins 10 of 27 precincts but loses the count of the eligible to be counted votes.

Does not bode well, no?

BETHLEHEM TOWNSHIP 


Of some solace to Werren, he wins the count of the eligible uncounted by 1 vote.

He reduces Hartnett's lead to 43 votes.

CANAL FULTON


In Canal Fulton Hartnett "holds serve."  She won all four precincts in the "unofficial" count and she more than doubled Werren on the uncounted eligible to be counted voters.

At the Canal Fulton point of the uncounted eligible to be counted votes, Hartnett leads by 48 votes.

"Holding serve" was a feat that Werren was not able to accomplish in Alliance where he won 10 of 17 precincts.

CANTON CITY


No surprise here.

Canton, a Democratic stronghold.

Hartnett picks up 28 votes to increase her lead to 76 votes.

CANTON TOWNSHIP



if Curt Werren was privvy (which he wasn't, of course) to the counting of the eligible to be counted uncounted vote, he undoubtedly taken heart (presuming an "in alphabetical order" process) when the count reached Canton Township.

He outpolls Hartnett by four votes thereby reducing her lead to 72 votes.

And Republican strongholds Jackson and Lake township are next up on the alphabetical list.

"Hope, springs eternal," no?

JACKSON TOWNSHIP




Though Republican Werren did win a majority of Jackson's precincts (Jackson is a predominantly Republican part of Stark County), he did not gain votes on Democrat Hartnett.

By the SCPR's count he actually lost one vote.

Hartnett up 73 on Werren after the Jackson count.

What a disappointment for Werren, no?

LAKE TOWNSHIP



If the Jackson results on counting of eligible uncounted votes is disappointing to Werren, it is likely that the Lake count is even moreso.

A leading Stark County Republican told the SCPR before Friday's release of the count that the hope for a turn Werren's way was in Lake Township.

In Lake he won all but five precincts and there were 111 uncounted votes that predominantly go to Werren.

But the actual count only produced a four vote pick up.

After Lake, Hartnett's margin stands at 69.

Lake is about the alphabetical midpoint of the count and things are not looking good for Werren.

He has dropped 40 votes from the unofficial count showing Hartnett up 29 votes.

Many of us who do political/voting pattern analysis believe that Democrats have more trouble voting no matter the voting district.

The SCPR's take on voting so far is that more provisional ballots even in strong Republican area of Stark County seem to fit the stereotype that those ballots were predominantly cast by Democrats.

While Republcan Werren did have a margin in Lake, it was a small one.  Jackson was a virtual tie.

LAWRENCE TOWNSHIP



Hartnett took four of the five Lawrence Township precincts.  And, much more truer to form in terms of a correlation between Harnett dominating in a particular city, village or township than with Werren, a Harnett dominance in a given geographical unit usually spells a significant increase in her vote total.

By the SCPR's vote tally, she picked up six votes in Lawrence which increases her lead to 75.

LEXINGTON TOWNSHIP




Hartnett and Werren split Lexington Township.

Yet Hartnett walked away with a net gain of seven to 82 votes to bring her over Werren.

LOUISVILLE




Another downer for Werren.  He wins six of seven Louisville precincts but Hartnett increases her lead by one vote.

MARLBORO TOWNSHIP



Matters are "really" looking dire when a Republican loses a net calculated provisional vote in Marlboro Township.

To the SCPR it is really weird that two of the most Republican areas in Stark County are Marlboro and Tuscarawas townships.

Both are "working class" communities that seem to have little in common with the likes of Jackson and Lake which are two of Stark's financial better off areas of Stark County.

Despite being a sweep for Werren, Hartnett still picked up another one vote increase in Marlboro which put her at 83.

MASSILLON



Whew!  Was Massillon good for Chryssa Hartnett or was Massillon good?

A net gain of 18 votes to bring her total increase to 101.

All over but the shouting, no?

Massillon, if properly worked, is an out-and-out Democratic Party city pretty much the equal of Canton.

Democratic voters may stumble and bumble to the polls and may have trouble getting things straight on voting procedures but enough of them negotiated the terrain so as to give Hartnett a commanding lead.

MYERS LAKE & NAVARRE


in Myers Lake a reprieve for Curt Werren.

He gets Hartnett under 100 with his net two vote pick up of provisionals.

But the reprieve is short lived.

When one considers the different proportions (i.e. number of Massilion voters to Navarre voters), as impressive as Massillon was for Hartnett, Navarre is the champ during this election.

Little Navarre, Stark County, Ohio delivers eight (net) additional votes for Hartnett and thereby helps mightily as Stark's newest judge-elect increased her margin to 107 votes over Curt Werren.

NIMISHILLEN TOWNSHIP




Deja-vu-all-over-again for Curt Werren in Nimishillen Township which surrounds Louisville.

Werren wins six of seven precincts but loses ground to Hartnett:  a net of two votes.

Consequently, Hartnett increased her lead to 109 votes.

NORTH CANTON


It was "high-five" time for the Werren camp with the North Canton counting of provisionals.

Werren picked up 15 votes on Hartnett in the community which he calls home.

Unfortunately for him, the Republican strongholds are already known by the time we get to North Canton.

And, it did so poorly in these area (compared to expectations) that the North Canton boost will turnout to be a "feel encouraged for the moment" phenomenon.

But after North Canton Hartnett's net lead is down to 94.

Not great.  But heading in the right direction.

OSNABURG (EAST CANTON)


Another standoff voting district.

Werren and Hartnet split the precincts and each got six votes and, accordingly, there is no movement in the overall number.

PARIS TOWNSHIP INCLUDING MINERVA



A voting district that was on November 4th was solidly Republican.  Werren wins all five precincts yet only picks up one net vote on Hartnett.

Again, the SCPR thinks that Werren's misfortune (i.e. one would think that winning all precincts would show up in vote gains of provisionals) is wrapped up in the political reality that Democrat or Democrat leaning voters have voting problems more than Republicans that resulted in their casting "to be counted later, if at all" ballots.

Paris/Minerva was Werren's last chance to eat into the Hartnett's lead and, perhaps, provide a spark of hope that a recount of the entire vote might spot an electronic glitch to turn things his way.

But only picking up a net gain of one vote doesn't help that cause at all, no?

PERRY TOWNSHIP


Perry Township was definitely on November 4th Chryssa Hartnett territory.  She won 15 (one tied) of the 19 precincts.

Somewhat odd is that she picked up "only" five votes on Werren.

Hmm?

PIKE TOWNSHIP INCLUDING EAST SPARTA


A much smaller voting district than Perry Township and yet Pike Township produced a net gain of two votes for Hartnett.  And Werren wins this district two precincts to one and over all by a comfortable margins.

When are Democrats and Democratic leaning voters going to learn how to vote correctly (i.e. not having to vote provisionally)?

Just kidding (sort of).

But "hmm," anyway!

PLAIN TOWNSHIP
(STARK'S MOST POPULATED)


Another revealing count that showed that Democrats have the most difficulty voting "trouble" free.

Werren wins Plain 21 precincts to Hartnett's nine (1), but loses 12 votes (net) in the overall count of the provisionals including absentee ballots.

Two of Plain's 30 precincts were very close, but still it begs the point to see that Werren wins comfortably in 19 of the 30 precincts but slides precipitously in the provisional/absentee count.

With the Plain result, it appears to the SCPR that "all hope is lost" for Werren in the overall recount that is to come.

SANDY TOWNSHIP (MAGNOLIA & WAYNESBURG)


This is "icing on the cake" time for the Hartnett campaign.

Three (net gain) votes for Hartnett in Sandy Township.

SUGARCREEK TOWNSHIP (BREWSTER)


And more "icing on the cake" in Sugarcreek Township.  Three (3) more net to the plus votes for Hartnett.

TUSCARAWAS TOWNSHIP


Back to stalemate.

Neither Hartnett nor Werren gain in Tuscarawas Township.

WASHINGTON TOWNSHIP


And Washington wraps of The Stark County Political Report's analysis with still more stalemate.

CONCLUSION

All-in-all "impressive" for the Hartnett campaign, "pathetic" for the Werren campaign.

Though Werren got much better Stark County Republican Party support than Larry Dordea did for his sheriff campaign, Werren still lost.

It is obvious that the message got out to the voting public that Chryssa Hartnett on the basis of her sterling career as a Stark County prosecutor was eminently more qualified that Werren is to be a judge.

Most observers that the SCPR conversed with felt that Werren would prove to be at least "a workmanlike judge."

And that may be the case.

However, when it comes to the administration of justice why would Stark Countians want to chance "workmanlike" when the prospect of "excellence" is at hand with Judge-elect Chryssa Hartnett.

For this prospect, the SCPR thanks:

  • Chyssa Hartnett for "staying the course" and persisting even though twice rejected by a governor who in selecting Werren was playing politics with the administration of justice, and
  • "last, but certainly not least," the Stark County voting public for "rightly" dividing the "political" for the "merited."
Undoubtedly, the Republicans will answer that the Democrat do it too.

That is not an acceptable answer.

To answer that way is to advance a reason that goes to "the heart and soul" of why Stark Countians, Ohioans and American increasing reject the governance that both Democrats and Republicans offer up.

Shame on both of these political parties for "feathering their own nests" at the expense of the interest of the American citizenry.

If we one day lose our treasured democratic-republic, the specific names in Stark County, Ohio and across the land that bleed Democratic Party and Republican Party self-interest politics are the people to specifically "to point the finger of blame at."

Now is the time to name names of the offenders.

For once we lose our cherished institutions of government and politics, IT WILL BE TOO LATE!!!

============================

And, thank you Stark Countians for coming to the SCPR to get your most complete and thorough analysis of Stark County politics/governance that is to be had in Stark County!

Thursday, November 20, 2014

SCPR CONTINUING ELECTION COVERAGE: IS HARTNETT IN DRIVER'S SEAT ON UNCOUNTED BALLOTS?



UPDATED AT 7:00 AM

As only The Stark County Political Report does, The Report obtained a listing from the Stark County Board of Elections (BOE) of these Stark County precincts in which there are "uncounted" provisional ballots (regular) and provisional absentee ballots.

There are 1217 of such votes.  But only 1175 are going to be counted.  A unanimous (all four BOE members) board vote determined that a number of said ballots (along with some absentee ballots) are defective as a matter of law and therefore not eligible to be counted.

Those 1175 votes will likely (there could be a tie, no?) the contest between Curtis Werren (the Republican who was the beneficiary of a Republican John Kasich gubernatorial appointment in June, 2013 to succeed the retired V. Lee Sinclair), and Stark County chief prosecutor Chryssa Hartnett.

Hartnett finished with an "unofficial" 29 vote lead late in the night on November 4th.


It used be that it was "finger nail biting time" on recounts mandated or paid for by a challenging candidate in this country in razor thin election results.

But not so much anymore with the advent of electronic vote counting machines.

However, with federal legislation a number years ago, we Americans have invented a new drama into our voting and vote counting process:  "the provisional 'paper' ballot."

Absentee ballots are nothing new.  But the "stragglers" that come in after election day but postmarked on election day or before are relatively few in number.

The provisionals can be and in this election are quite a different matter.  In this election they outnumber the countable absentees 1,044 to 131.

Beginning with North Canton precinct 2D (Ward 2 is represented by North Canton Council president Daniel "Jeff" Peters [a colleague of Werren's wife Stephanie who represents Ward 3]) which (2D) was a Curtis Warren precinct in this election by a margin (unofficial count) of 57 votes; it might appear - at first glance - that in the contest of whom is going to be the elected judge that Curtis Werren has the advantage in that 2D, at 17 provisional ballots, is the top provisional voting precinct in all of Stark County.

However, the SCPR's take is that overall, it may be that challenger Hartnett has the advantage.

Of the top tier (five or more provisionals) of provisional ballot precincts, Hartnett won the precinct original "unofficial" count in 50 precincts whereas Werren won in 38 precincts.

For all precincts (provisionals and absentees), Hartnett won the original "unofficial" count in 150 precincts whereas Werren won 133.  One precinct ended in a tie (Jackson #19, 153 to 153).

Of course, nobody knows for sure as trying to figure out what type of voter (Republican, Democrat, conservative, liberal, rich, poor, middle income or any other tip off) voted and how a particular voter may have voted is a guess at best.

The SCPR is being told that the Werren camp is pinning its hopes on Lake Township.


Werren won 18 of Lake's 23 precincts.

In Lake there were 95 provisional "paper" ballots and 13 "late" but countable absentee ballots cast.

Precinct 15 stands out as a possible "treasure trove" for Werren supporters.  Werren won the precinct by a commanding 133 vote margin.

Could those 11 and the one absentee be decidedly for Werren?

If so, Lake, indeed, could be "a game changer" for those Stark Countians who want to see Werren elected.

So it stands to reason that Lake could be a key in turning the overall "official" and "certified" vote Werren's way.

The SCPR has sorted a spreadsheet file provided to The Report on request by Travis Secrest of the BOE and here is result of the sort.
  • SCPR Notes:
    • The colors (blue for Hartnett, red for Werren) were added by the SCPR)
    • Vote differentials and who won/lost precinct votes were tabulated by the SCPR; not the Stark BOE